Elevate Your Southern Indiana Real Estate Experience With
How Can I Help You?
-
Buy a Home
Find the right home in Evansville, Newburgh, Jasper, Santa Claus and beyond. Explore neighborhoods and search homes for sale.
-
Sell Your Home
Get a free, no-obligation market analysis and a custom marketing plan, including a professional video of your home.
-
Join Key Associates
Grow your real estate career with the #4 brokerage in the region, backed by coaching, training and a team that has your back.
Whether you've seen one of my videos, stumbled upon my website, or a trusted friend pointed you in my direction, I'm thrilled you're here. I'm here to be your guiding light in the world of real estate. I'm all about bringing positivity, energy, and a whole lot of expertise to the table! With a solid foundation in market trends, negotiation finesse, property valuation know-how, and all the legal ins and outs, I've got your back every step of the way. Over the last five years, I've closed 380 sales totaling $85.8 million for my clients.
Kara is the managing broker & owner of Key Associates Signature Realty, a fast growing real estate brokerage serving Southern Indiana & Northern Kentucky that fosters a culture of collaboration, communication, trust, innovation, and integrity, ensuring that every client and agent feels empowered and championed throughout their journey.
Ranked the #4 BROKERAGE
in the region by sales volume
Empowering over 600 clients annually with their real estate endeavors
One of the Top-Followed Real Estate firms in the area
Served as the listing brokerage for
"The Most Expensive Home in the Midwest”
as recognized by Architectural Digest
What a journey it’s been! In 2025, my clients and I closed $16 million in sales, and 2026 is already ahead of that with $17.9 million closed so far this year. I’m truly humbled and grateful – but to me, it’s so much more than the numbers. It’s about the memories, the milestones, and the trust you placed in me during one of life’s most exciting (and sometimes nerve-wracking) journeys.
To my clients, you are the heart of what I do. Every key handed over, every celebration, and even every challenge has made this year so rewarding. To my friends, family, and community, your support, referrals, and encouragement have meant the world.
From the bottom of my heart, thank you for letting me be a part of your story this year. I can’t wait to see what’s ahead as we continue turning dreams into keys together!
With love and gratitude,
CUSTOM VIDEOS,
WHEN YOU LIST WITH ME!
Property videos on social media offer a captivating visual experience that engages potential buyers and sets your listings apart in a crowded market. When you list with me I’ll go the extra mile with a custom, tailored video.
What My Clients Are Saying
Frequently Asked Questions About Working With Kara
-
Kara Hinshaw is a Realtor and the managing broker and owner of Key Associates Signature Realty, based in Santa Claus, Indiana. She has more than 20 years of real estate experience and helps buyers and sellers across Southern Indiana and Northern Kentucky.
-
I work throughout Southern Indiana, including Santa Claus and Christmas Lake Village, Evansville, Newburgh, Jasper, Dale, Ferdinand, Huntingburg and Tell City, as well as parts of Northern Kentucky.
-
Over the last five years, I've closed 380 sales totaling $85.8 million. Key Associates Signature Realty is ranked the #4 brokerage in the region by sales volume.
-
Yes. I help buyers find the right home, and I help sellers price, market and sell their homes, including a custom listing video. Sellers can start with a free market analysis to see what their home is worth.
-
Yes. I've sold everything from starter homes to luxury estates, including lake homes in Christmas Lake Village. My brokerage was the listing brokerage for Big Tree Farm, which Architectural Digest featured as the most expensive home in the Midwest.
-
Call or text me at 812-686-3268, email karahinshaw@keyassociates.com, or send a message through the contact form on this site. I'd love to hear about your plans.
As a luxury real estate agent based in Indiana, I'm honored to be frequently featured in articles by well-known media outlets. My commitment to delivering unparalleled service and showcasing exquisite properties has made me a trusted authority in the industry, earning recognition for my dedication to excellence and attention to detail.
Unlock the secrets to skyrocketing your real estate empire
Join me on my socials for daily insider tips and strategies guaranteed to supercharge your business growth
Ready to dive into the excitement of living in Indiana or Kentucky? Eager to unravel the mysteries of real estate transactions? Interested in staying on top of market trends or propelling your real estate career to new heights? Look no further than my vibrant YouTube channels! I'm passionate about creating engaging videos and fully grasp the pivotal role they play in today's society. Get ready for weekly updates and insights to keep you informed and entertained!
Exclusive Home Tips Delivered Monthly!
Sign up for my exclusive monthly newsletter and elevate your home and lifestyle! Each edition is filled with the latest home design trends, festive holiday activities, delicious recipes, and expert gardening tips. Join my community to stay informed and inspired with valuable insights and creative ideas delivered right to your inbox. Don't miss out—subscribe today and transform your living space into a stylish and inviting haven!
